?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Facebook: Spam Factory - Riffs and Licks
steelbrassnwood
steelbrassnwood
Facebook: Spam Factory
I joined Facebook a few months ago, to keep up with some friends and colleagues who aren't part of the other social networks I belong to, and to keep abreast of social networking in general, which interests me professionally. Each of the networks I belong to has a purpose: LJ is a blogging platform and a way to keep up with friends who blog regularly and to whom I'm close enough to share fairly intimate details of my life; its filtering capabilities allow me to have concentric rings of friends who see different levels of detail. Myspace is strictly for music networking, and works quite well for that purpose despite its horrendous user interface.

Facebook filled a gap: it let me keep abreast of people who don't blog or to whom I am not close enough to want to share detailed blog entries. It's the best way for me to keep up with my many former colleagues, and its telegraphic style makes it possible to actively watch a very long friends list.

Or, it used to. Facebook has gotten increasingly problematic. Even though I have set my preferences to the contrary, my news feed is filling up with so much spam and crap that I miss significant updates (like new photos) by friends from whom I really want to see updates. I turned off email notifications because the vast majority of them were notes not from friends, but from applications my friends had installed. I mostly ignore those requests, but I was becoming increasingly puzzled by the amount of spam I was getting. Had all of my otherwise rational friends suddenly turned into junk-mail-forwarders?

I decided to accept a few requests and see what was going on. I went through eleven screens to read a one-line Christmas card message from one person, tried to return a thrown snowball to someone else (and after ten or twelve screens gave up entirely), and tried to share music through iLike. None of these applications worked properly, and all of them did their best to trick me into spamming everyone in sight. I've documented my interaction with one particularly deceptive application below, but this is pretty much standard behavior for most third-party Facebook applications. It is very difficult to install these applications without spamming your friends; they mislead or tell outright lies in order to get you to do so, and in this case, even ignoring it entirely won't help.






Step 1: The come-on Step 1: The come-on
This item showed up in my news feed this morning. I clicked to view my friend's message.

Step 2: The sales pitch Step 2: The sales pitch
Oh, I'm adding an application? Why do I have to do that just to read a message? OK, let's give this a try. For the sake of this experiment, I'll agree to the terms of use and grant all these permissions to this unknown application that's already sorta-lied to me.

Step 3: Spam Step 3: Spam
Now things are getting really sneaky. In this frame (altered to protect everyone's identity), you select friends "whose messages you want to see" but what's really happening is that you're sending them spam asking them to add the application.

Step 4: More spam Step 4: More spam
I'm being prompted here again to send spam (not even to a selected list). I still haven't seen my friend's message.

Step 5: And more spam Step 5: And more spam
Yet another opportunity to spam my friends. I still haven't seen the message.

Step 6: Still more spam Step 6: Still more spam
More spam for my friends. Still no message.

Step 7: Spam spam spam spam Step 7: Spam spam spam spam
More spam. No message. Note the very tiny "skip" link at the bottom you need to find in order to avoid spamming people; if you "unselect all" and click Forward, you get an error message.

Step 8: I give up! Step 8: I give up!
I picked one friend in the previous screen and sent a spam, to see if I could get out of the loop and finally read the message. No such luck. So at this point I just clicked back to my news feed, and again clicked there to read X's message.

Step 9: The punchline Step 9: The punchline
My friend, whose message I was trying to read, doesn't even have the application! He or she (I refused to do the moronic Faceboook thing of referring to individuals as "they") ignored the spam that some other friend had sent. If I'd been less careful in installing this app, I would have not only spammed my friends, but THEIR friends as well. To be clear: person Y installed this stupid application and fell for one of the screens that deceives you into sending spam. Person X, my friend, is a friend of person Y, got this spam, and ignored it, never reading person Y's message. Yet I still got spam that pretended to be something relevant to person X, in turn attempting to deceive me into the same trick. This is deceptive, unacceptable behavior, and as a result my usage of, and respect for, Facebook is dwindling rapidly.



So, to my Facebook friends, it's not that I don't appreciate your sending me gifts and cards and attacking me with your werewolf. I'm up for a snowball fight anytime you want to come over (assuming we get some snow). But I won't be accepting any more of these invitations.

Tags: ,

11 comments or Leave a comment
Comments
kibbles From: kibbles Date: January 4th, 2008 04:48 pm (UTC) (Link)
Yeah I stopped most of that stuff. Annoys me. And none of my friends seem to care that I don't ninja pirate them back or whatever.
steelbrassnwood From: steelbrassnwood Date: January 4th, 2008 04:57 pm (UTC) (Link)
To top it all off, after being (I thought) careful going through those screens, my news feed has four items in it about all the spam I sent. (I sent one deliberately, but I never intended to send 72 of anything.)

I suspect the application ignored me and sent spam even though I unchecked people, but maybe I missed something somewhere. That's not the point; even when installed by a relatively sophisticated user who's trying not to send spam, this application still sends a ton of spam.




Edited at 2008-01-04 04:58 pm (UTC)
rosefox From: rosefox Date: January 4th, 2008 06:14 pm (UTC) (Link)
Today's Wondermark hits this spot on:

steelbrassnwood From: steelbrassnwood Date: January 4th, 2008 06:30 pm (UTC) (Link)
I love it! XKCD had a good one a few weeks ago too:

chamisa From: chamisa Date: January 5th, 2008 02:21 am (UTC) (Link)
Hee hee! That is so spot on!
From: egretplume Date: January 4th, 2008 07:13 pm (UTC) (Link)
I found Facebook so annoying that I left it.
It sounds like it has only got worse.
I would rather just email people I actually want to talk to.
steelbrassnwood From: steelbrassnwood Date: January 4th, 2008 07:50 pm (UTC) (Link)
Well, emails get lost, or are left unanswered, or whatever; FB is a very quick way to see what 50 or 100 people are up to, which I like. I'm fine with the concept; it's the pollution of the news feed that's irritating me.
blue_eye From: blue_eye Date: January 4th, 2008 07:25 pm (UTC) (Link)
I learned that one very early on. I just started using my Facebook awhile back and it's mostly for the reasons you use it (I also like your description on LJ filters in "concentric circles"...I do that as well). Lucky for me, I have no patience in clicking through multiple screens. Not only that, I get very sqeemish regarding "adding applications." I am paranoid about viruses and such. The one that made me crack up was you can "poke" people, which is fine...people have "poked" me to get my attention, but "superpoke?" C'Mon!
steelbrassnwood From: steelbrassnwood Date: January 4th, 2008 07:52 pm (UTC) (Link)
Yeah, really. "Superpoke" sounds vaguely obscene. I was completely stymied by "poking" when I first joined, wondering what I was missing. Then I realized I wasn't missing anything -- there was nothing there to miss.
chamisa From: chamisa Date: January 5th, 2008 02:23 am (UTC) (Link)
I so do not miss Facebook! What you describe is one of the reasons why I did decide to leave it, not just "Beacon".
rednoodlealien From: rednoodlealien Date: January 5th, 2008 05:55 pm (UTC) (Link)
I refused to do the moronic Faceboook thing of referring to individuals as "they"

What makes it inexcusable is that the gender of most users is right there in "their" profile.
11 comments or Leave a comment